Showing posts with label Victoria Criminal Justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Victoria Criminal Justice. Show all posts

Monday, April 2, 2012

Time for national debate on evil drug trade

Eddie McGuire | Sunday Herald Sun | April 01, 2012 

THE APPALLING HUMAN COST OF ILLICIT DRUGS IS TOO HIGH AND WE NEED TO CONSIDER OTHER SOLUTIONS INCLUDING DECRIMINALISING THE TRADE, ARGUES EDDIE MCGUIRE. 

I HATE drugs. I hate their guts. I hate the human misery that the illicit drug industry thrives on.

How could you not be devastated by the situation in which Ben Cousins and his family find themselves?

How do two beautiful girls I went to primary school with have their lives brutally ended being bashed to death while working the streets of St Kilda to feed a habit?

But what to do?

Well, clearly something different. It is time for Australia to look at so many of our social and economic needs and plan a course not built on tradition and religion and moral mumbo jumbo, but on reality and innovation. Time for some politicians to boldly lead.

It's time for Australia to look seriously at decriminalising drugs.

The war on drugs is over. We lost. If the definition of madness is doing the same thing over again and expecting a different result, then surely we are all mad to think anything is going to get better in the future.

It's only getting worse and those profiting out of the sale and manufacturing of drugs, organised crime cartels, are only getting bigger, badder and richer.

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Populist approach to violence hardly good public policy

Josh Gordon | The Age | December 8, 2011


Melbourne is a safe place to live, so what's all the hysteria about?

Melbourne is a bad-ass town. At least it is according to outspoken Liberal MP Bernie Finn, who recently told his local paper that parts had become so dangerous automatic weaponry was needed.

''Places like Werribee, Sunshine, Williamstown . . . have suffered for a long time,'' he said. There are places . . . without a flak jacket and a sub-machinegun you just wouldn't go there.''

Finn was no doubt being colourful, as is his custom. But the comments underscore a growing sense of hysteria being encouraged by some political figures and members of the commentariat.

You might be forgiven for thinking Melbourne is in danger of being overrun by ''thugs'' (a word that incidentally derives from the Hindi ''thuggee'', who were members of an extinct Indian robber cult who killed their victims with knotted scarves) who have been allowed to ride roughshod by liberal-minded judges.

But, according to analyst Economist Intelligence Unit in its global liveability survey, Melbourne has once again overtaken Vancouver as the world's most liveable city. It is one of the safest places to live in the world.

In 2010-11 there were 6429 crimes committed for every 100,000 Victorians, a fall of 3.9 per cent compared with the previous year, and the lowest since comparable records began in 1993.

While it is true that the rate of so-called crimes ''against the person'' increased by 4 per cent, as new Police Commissioner Ken Lay points out, this has had much to do with the burgeoning problem of family-related violence. Crimes linked to family incidents, for example, leapt by an alarming 26 per cent in the year. In contrast, other crimes against the person increased by just 0.1 per cent (murders fell sharply).

The bottom line is that it is difficult to say whether Melbourne's streets are becoming less safe. Even if you accept they are, it is simplistic to blame hoons, thugs and louts, as if they represent a new subspecies of humanity.

The Baillieu government's populist approach to law and order has been its controversial tough-on-crime agenda, which includes the abolition of suspended sentences and home detention, minimum jail terms (except in extenuating circumstances) for 16 and 17-year-olds who commit acts of gross violence and new ''baseline'' minimum sentences.

A better approach would be to focus on ''upstream'' causes, rather than tackling ''downstream'' symptoms.

Killer's sharp suit fails to dress up a hollow tale

John Silvester | The Age | September 30, 2011



Matthew Johnson in the clothes he has worn most of his adult life.

THE man in the witness box doesn't look like an institutionalised inmate and one of the most dangerous men in Australia.

In his well cut shark-grey suit and matching tie he could pass for a fitness-conscious stockbroker: the type that chooses the shaved head look favoured by many modern metrosexuals.

There are no signs of jail tattoos, body piercings or battle scars to hint at the man's 20-year criminal history that now includes 159 criminal convictions - the last added yesterday when a Supreme Court jury found him guilty of murdering underworld identity Carl Williams inside Barwon Prison.

Yet at his first appearance to testify there are signs that the outfit is not the witness's daily business attire but clothes bought to impress the jury. On the sleeve of the brand new suit are four spare buttons, still loosely attached by a piece of tailor's cloth. The back slit on the jacket is held together by a single temporary stitch - a sure sign it is fresh from a store rack rather than a private wardrobe.

Over three days in the witness box, Matthew Johnson stuck to his improbable story, that he killed Williams in self-defence. His barrister, Bill Stuart, argued through the trial it was a case of ''kill or be killed''.

Such a position was somewhat eroded when the jury saw prison video of Johnson attacking Williams from behind on April 19 last year, beating him eight times over the head with the metal stem of an exercise bike and dragging him into his cell.

There they saw Johnson in the clothes he has worn most of his adult life: the prison garb of red T-shirt and shorts.

In the witness box, Johnson maintained he believed Williams was planning to kill him using four billiard balls inside a sock as a weapon. His voice was controlled, his answers measured and his version of events - totally unbelievable.

Even Johnson didn't seem confident the jurors would swallow his story. ''The moment I made up me mind to kill Carl, I just assumed that the next 30 to 40 years I'm spending in jail,'' he told them.

The exact number of years will now be decided by Justice Lex Lasry at a later sentencing date but Johnson's estimation seems certain to be around the mark.

When the jury of seven women and five men returned their verdict after 14 hours of deliberation, Johnson showed no emotion. The decision would hardly have surprised the career criminal who knew this day was coming from the time he launched his premeditated attack 19 months earlier.

Monday, December 12, 2011

Lawyers fear rise in use of capsicum spray

Alison Caldwell | ABC Online |  5 December 2011

Lawyers in Victoria say they fear recent changes to the Victoria Police manual could lead police to use capsicum spray or foam more often.

Capsicum spray, also known as pepper spray, is a crowd control weapon which makes the skin and eyes sting and burn.

The spray has been in the news worldwide because of the Occupy protests and two police officers in California were recently suspended after they used the spray on protesting university students.

AUDIO: Concerns police will use capsicum spray more often (PM)

Police in Victoria have been using the spray on offenders since 1998.

Until recently the police manual provided guidelines for the use of capsicum spray, including when it should and should not be used on a person.

The manual used to state the spray or foam should not be used "when a person is passively resisting arrest such as hanging limp or refusing to comply with instructions."

But that guideline was removed from the police manual last year.

Melbourne lawyer Anthony Kelly, from the Flemington and Kensington Community Legal Centre, says he is concerned police will start to use capsicum spray more liberally.

"Our major concerns are that when capsicum spray was first introduced it was very clearly specified that it should only be used in really violent or confrontational situations of serious physical confrontation," he said.

"But more and more we're seeing the use of capsicum spray against people who are simply non-compliant with police orders - so against prisoners, against people in custody, but also against protesters who are peaceful and are engaged in what's sometimes called passive resistance or non-violent civil disobedience.

"Prior to February last year there were very clear guidelines that it should only be used in situations of violence and serious physical confrontation ... and those guidelines have now been removed from the recent edition.

"We're concerned that police are more likely to use capsicum spray against people who are engaged in non-violent protest, peaceful protest."

Sunday, November 13, 2011

Crack appears in juvenile detention plan

Farah Farouque | The Age | 10 November 2011

A CHINK has emerged in the Baillieu government's law and order crackdown as it confirmed plans to defer mandatory minimum custodial sentences for youths aged 16 and 17 convicted of ''gross violence'' offences.

While the government says it is still committed to the controversial laws to incarcerate teenagers, legislation introducing four-year minimum prison terms for adults convicted of the violence offences will proceed first.

Laws tackling adults will be introduced in the first tranche next year, leaving time to consult further on two-year minimum youth detention terms for juvenile offenders - a concession welcomed by the legal profession.

Attorney-General Robert Clark was responding yesterday after a key expert body said that when teenagers were charged with gross violence offences such cases should be automatically transferred out of the Children's Court into the jurisdiction of a higher court where they would be afforded more rights.

Professor Arie Freiberg, chairman of the Sentencing Advisory Council, said it was important ''not to compromise the operation of sentencing'' in the Children's Court, which included rehabilitation.

Professor Freiberg said the council had not been asked to assess the merits of the government's election commitment to introduce statutory minimum sentences for gross violence offences, subject to limited exceptional circumstances.

But the council's report noted most submissions it had received on children from bodies ranging from the Victorian Bar and the Law Institute to the Uniting Church argued that a minimum sentence should not be applied to juveniles.

Incoming Law Institute president Michael Holcroft said he hoped to persuade the government to abandon the plans to incarcerate more juveniles.

"We will be working with the government to do all we can to ensure that the focus for dealing with juvenile offenders is on rehabilitation rather than ensuring they follow a life of crime beginning in a youth justice centre," he said.

In the report, which Mr Clark has been considering since September, the council proposed that two new offences be created to cover circumstances involving ''gross violence''.

The proposed offences are: intentionally causing severe injury and recklessly causing severe injury.

The council has urged that ''severe'' injury be defined in the legislation to cover ''injuries of a long-term nature involving serious impairment to, or loss of, a body function or serious disfigurement''. Such injuries would also cover loss of a foetus.

Professor Freiberg noted that at present the gradation between causing ''injury'' and ''serious injury'' was vague. The Court of Appeal had held that injuries such as two black eyes and a grazed forehead could constitute ''serious injury'' and, given the potential for loss of liberty under the new laws, there should be a higher injury threshold for gross violence.

Saturday, November 5, 2011

Vandals to clean own mess

Nino Bucci | The Age | 20 October 2011

IT STARTS with a can of spray paint and often ends behind bars.

But Frankston police are confident a new program will stop the first graffiti mark leading to a lengthy criminal history.

For the first time in Victoria, youths facing a criminal damage offence can have the charges dropped if they take part in a program that includes painting over daubed walls.

Frankston City Council spends almost $400,000 each year removing graffiti from about 30,000 square metres of property.

Senior Constable Renee Bloomfield, who developed the program as youth resource officer, said too often police dealt with offenders who started as teenage vandals before graduating to more serious crime. The program will be launched today and rolled out more widely if the pilot proves successful.

''The earlier the young person enters the criminal justice system the greater the likelihood they are going to remain embroiled within it,'' she said. ''If we can get a young person at 13 or 14 and put that intervention in place we can stop that cycle.''

Thursday, September 15, 2011

Judge calls for sex trials rethink

Farah Farouque | The Age | September 8, 2011

SOME accused sex offenders should be dealt with outside the traditional courts in a system similar to South Africa's truth and reconciliation commissions where they meet and hear from victims, says one of Victoria's most senior judges.

Justice Marcia Neave, of the Court of Appeal, told The Age she was deeply concerned that conviction rates for sexual assaults remained ''very, very low'' and guilty pleas had plunged, despite law reforms in the past decade. Victoria's criminal justice system was not working for victims of sex offences, despite changes to court rules and systems to accommodate their needs, she said.

It was time for policymakers to consider a radical alternative to traditional courts by diverting some sex offenders, including alleged rapists, into a system where they made admissions and met their victims in ''conference'' settings. The victims, or a spokesperson for them, would explain how their lives had been affected and discuss reparations - commonly the offender enrolling in a treatment program. No conviction would be recorded.

Both victim and offender would consent to participate under the plan, echoing principles used in the truth and reconciliation commission system that applied after the end of apartheid in South Africa.

As a first step, the idea should be tested in Victoria for carefully selected juvenile sex offenders, including those accused of rape, and perhaps also some adults accused of sex crimes that were decades old and hard to prove beyond reasonable doubt in a criminal court.

''If you can use truth and reconciliation in the context of the apartheid regime in South Africa, in the context of the terrible things that happened in East Timor with the militias, then you might be able to use it in [this sexual offence] context,'' the judge said.

Justice Neave plans to raise the idea, which she conceded was controversial and might be a hard-sell politically in Spring Street, in a paper she will give at an Australasian Institute of Judicial Administration conference in Sydney today.

The paper cites statistics including that fewer than 20 per cent of sexual assault victims report the offences to police. In Victoria, from 2004-05 to 2008-09 a conviction was recorded in about 50 per cent of sex cases that went to trial in the County Court. By 2009-10, the conviction rate had fallen to 38 per cent.

''It must be accepted that some allegations of sexual assault may be false or mistaken … [but] the vast majority of true allegations do not result in any redress through the criminal justice system,'' the paper says.

Before becoming a judge, Justice Neave chaired the Victorian Law Reform Commission, which recommended major changes to court rules and systems for hearing sex assault cases. While acknowledging difficulty persuading the public and politicians her latest proposal was the right path, it was ''not impossible to persuade people that this might be a better outcome'', she said.

''If we are talking about a 17-year-old boy who offended against a neighbour's child - or against a member of his family - I don't think it's rocket science to say that putting this person away for a long period of time will not necessarily mean that he will be persuaded that what he did was wrong and won't do it again.''

Justice Neave said the ''restorative justice'' principle, used for young sex offenders in South Australia and overseas for violent offences, was not a soft option and often harder on the accused than traditional courts.

Under the path, sex offenders would be selected for the program under strict guidelines to be developed by the DPP, victims groups, defence lawyers and the judiciary. Repeat offenders would be excluded.

Justice Neave said she had spoken to many sex assault victims who were not concerned only with retribution. ''They want a voice in the process.''

Friday, September 2, 2011

Judge wants bench to 'reach out to victims'

Pia Akerman | The Australian | 1 September 2011

VICTORIA'S highest judge has admitted a gulf exists between the judiciary and victims of crime, proposing significant sentencing reforms to give victims and juries greater confidence in the legal system.

Supreme Court Chief Justice Marilyn Warren yesterday suggested judges should sit down with victims and their families after sentencing a criminal and explain in detail the reasons for the punishment.

"It is very frustrating for victims and their families where they have a sense of being a bystander when they go to court," she said. "There is a disconnection between us, and you wish to be just, but at the same time you are a compassionate human being and you would like to reach out."

In a move welcomed by victim support groups, she also floated trialling a US process where juries sit in on plea hearings and give recommendations to the judge on an appropriate sentence.

"The judge is the one in the middle who has to find a balance and deliver justice, but in terms of victims we still do not do enough," Chief Justice Warren said. "They do feel separated, alienated from the process.

"I can't help but wonder, if we sat down as judges and even just listened to the family after it was over, it might help."

A report released yesterday by the Victorian Sentencing Advisory Council found that only 28 per cent of 1200 people surveyed felt satisfied with court decisions, while 63 per cent thought judges were out of touch with what ordinary people thought.

Just over half were confident judges imposed appropriate sentences most of the time, and 59 per cent felt confident in the courts and legal system more generally.

Victims of crime had less confidence in the system than people who had not been victims.

Thursday, August 25, 2011

Ray Denning and lessons unlearnt in our justice system

Jack the Insider Blog | The Australian | 24 August 2011 

NSW Premier Barry O’Farrell deserves a round of applause. One of his election commitments was to examine the failures of the Bail Act (2007). In June of this year, the O’Farrell Government announced a judicial review into the Bail Act.

Retired NSW Supreme Court judge Hal Sperling QC will oversee the review which will report in November.

A promise made has been kept and Premier O’Farrell and his government gets a big tick.

The Bail Act was a flawed piece of legislation, driven largely by an appalling state Labor Government too eager to promote itself as being “tough on crime”.

Changes to the Bail Act created some very nasty unintended consequences. The policy wonks call it getting the settings wrong. But in human terms the costs are immeasurable or at least we won’t be able to measure them for some years to come.

Rates of youth detention skyrocketed in NSW; up by a third. Of those remanded in custody, only one third had committed subsequent offences. The overwhelming majority had been incarcerated awaiting trial for breaches of bail conditions, most commonly failing to comply with curfews. Many will await trial in custody for a year or more. Hopefully, the review will put a stop to this madness.

In Victoria, the Baillieu Government has run a “tough on crime” agenda. Ask the premier a question on transport, health or education and his brow quickly furrows but mention crime or God forbid, youth crime and he’ll go on for hours.

Now the Baillieu Government is moving forward with its plan to introduce mandatory minimum two year sentences for offenders between the age of 16 and 17 convicted of crimes involving violence.

It smacks of a stunt because sentencing data from the Children’s Court in Victoria shows that young violent offenders are not getting off easily. Secondly, a report from the Sentencing Advisory Council of Victoria reveals empirical evidence that longer sentences don’t act as a specific deterrent to offenders regardless of age.

In researching and creating the subjects and their histories for the documentary series, Tough Nuts on Foxtel’s CI Channel, one overwhelmingly common theme was the criminogenic effects of incarceration. In other words, that prisons and youth detention centres themselves are a major determinant of recidivism.

Our subjects were the worst of the worst: career criminals, mass murderers, drug dealers, people at the very top of the criminal hierarchy. They are the most notorious figures in Australian criminal history: Chris “Rentakill” Flannery, Dennis “Mr Death” Allen, Len “Mr Big” McPherson and John “The Magician” Regan.

Almost invariably they were products of a juvenile detention system where they were subjected to protracted physical and sexual abuse. Grafton Boys’ Home was the alma mater of any serious crook you could name from the 1970s and 80s; Stan “The Man” Smith, George Freeman, “Neddy” Smith and Len McPherson himself.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Sexting punishment is unjust says magistrate

Nicole Brady | SMH | August 14 2011

Teenagers have been placed on the sex offenders' register for sexting offences.

A SENIOR Victorian magistrate who presided over a case in which a youth pleaded guilty to teenage sexting offences has condemned as ''so unjust'' the mandatory laws that meant the young man was registered as a sex offender.

The magistrate, who works in country Victoria, said the lack of judicial discretion in such cases meant severe consequences for young people who posed no threat to society and were often guilty of little more than naivety.

The magistrate, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said he had made the unusual decision to speak out because he was troubled by cases recently identified by Fairfax.

He presided over the case of the country youth, then aged 18, who was sent four uninvited text message pictures of girls, aged between 15 and 17 years, topless or in their underwear. Police found the pictures on his mobile phone and laptop and charged him with child pornography offences.

On legal advice the youth pleaded guilty and was sentenced to a one-year good behaviour bond without conviction. The magistrate refused the prosecutor's application for the young man to be placed on the sex offender register but police later realised his guilty plea resulted in mandatory registration for eight years. Magistrates have discretion for those aged under 18, but none for adults.

''These people shouldn't be regarded as sex offenders. It's going beyond the pale in relation to the imposition of long-term penalties which are not judicial penalties, they're not fines or community-based orders or even sex offender treatment programs. This is a limitation on what a person can and can't do for the next eight years of their life, for God's sake,'' the magistrate said.

The magistrate said that in the sexting cases coming before him in court the offenders ''have a minimal amount of culpability attached to them and a minimal amount of danger to any other person in the community. That's when it becomes so unjust.''

He called for magistrates and judges to be given discretion over who ought to be listed as a sex offender. ''We're the ones that see the material, we hear the pleas from the legal practitioners, we get to hear the prior convictions if there are any, we get to see the actual participants - the people who have been involved in this sort of activity,'' he said.

Chief Magistrate Ian Gray declined to comment. Police Minister Peter Ryan, who oversees the sex offender register, declined to be interviewed.

The country magistrate said he first learnt of the rise of adolescent sexting - people sending naked or revealing pictures of themselves via their mobile phones or the internet - about two years ago from a police officer who had been talking to local school children.

''This person said to me there was serious concern that sexting was in epidemic proportions. If you hadn't had pictures taken with no gear on you were part of the outer scene.''

Under Victorian law, it is an offence to possess or transmit child pornography, which is defined as images showing those under 18 ''engaging in sexual activity or depicted in an indecent sexual manner or context''. Anyone over 18 found guilty of possessing or transmitting child pornography is automatically listed as a sex offender.

The Sex Offender Registration Act was brought in by the Labor government in 2004, with bipartisan support, to enable police to monitor paedophiles and other serious sex offenders.

The magistrate said some of the adolescent sexting material he had seen ''certainly is grossly pornographic and some of it almost makes you feel unwell''.

But he said the only harm in cases where such pictures had been forwarded to other people was to the girl in the pictures. While the consequences were often traumatising for the girl, the males involved were not paedophiles or serious sex offenders.

''The parties are no danger to the community, they're no danger to kids, it's an exercise in many cases in naivety, not even quite stupidity, just naivety,'' he said.

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

Lawyers challenge police alcohol ban powers

Peter Munro | The Age | 31 July 2011

POLICE powers to ban people from licensed venues could be challenged in the Supreme Court after a young woman was excluded for a year from every pub, bottle shop and licensed restaurant in her home town despite not being found guilty of any crime.

The 21-year-old was banned under a ''liquor accord'' between police and licensees from supermarket liquor outlets and licensed pizza shops, cafes and clubs in Swan Hill after being charged with apparently unrelated drugs offences. Similar bans under Victoria's liquor laws are limited to cases of alcohol-related violence or disorder.

Police appeared to be overstepping their powers, said Victorian Legal Aid's senior public defender, Saul Holt. ''She will be prevented for the next 12 months from attending 21st birthday parties of friends at licensed venues, prevented from having meals out with family at licensed venues and prevented from going to the supermarket,'' he said.

''A significant part of her ability to participate in community life has been stopped by this banning notice.''

Legal Aid was considering challenging the banning notice in the Supreme Court because there was no evidence that suggested their client was involved in any offence related to licensed premises, he said.

There are 89 liquor licence accords in Victoria with banning powers to combat alcohol-related crime. But the Swan Hill and District Liquor Industry Accord permits bans in connection with any alleged offence or breach of council by-laws. Bans are issued by police or licensees without court oversight. The only right of appeal is to a senior police officer.

''You could be banned from your local pub or club for littering outside a licensed premises, based on the way this particular accord is drafted,'' Mr Holt said.

''We don't have any difficulty per se with the power to do it in limited circumstances, such as when there is a very serious violent incident at a licensed premises. But it's the breadth and lack of oversight of these orders that concerns us.''

Sunday, July 31, 2011

Let there be order in court over Knight

James Campbell | Sunday Herald Sun | 31 July 2011

IF YOU are as old as I am, you probably remember where you were when you heard about what was at first called the Clifton Hill Massacre.

That Sunday night in August 1987, I was at home with the radio on when a report came in that a sniper was firing at cars on Hoddle St north of the Eastern Freeway. Within an hour the ABC was saying five people were dead and a man was in custody.

Next morning's Sun reported police as saying "the gunman, 19, of Ramsden St, Clifton Hill, had had military training".

In those pre-Port Arthur days, we thought this type of thing happened in the US, with its easy access to firearms. It seemed incredible that seven people could be randomly shot dead on a Sunday evening in the middle of Melbourne.

It seemed incredible, too, that the author of such an enormity should be a drunk teenager dismissed by an anonymous cop that week as "just a weed, a nothing".

Later, as we learned more about the Melbourne High School boy and failed Duntroon cadet, the more pathetic and less interesting he became.

His adopted parents had divorced when he was nine. He lived with his mother while idolising his absent father, a major in the army. Despite being clever, he performed poorly at school and lasted less than a year at Duntroon before being kicked out after a fracas in a Canberra nightclub. He later claimed to have been bullied.

What I recall people being intrigued about was not the character or motivation of this nothing, this weed, but how it was he was legally able own the M14 assault rifle, 12-gauge pump action and semi-automatic .22 he used in his crimes.

Maybe it is because Julian Knight and I are about the same age, but I remember so vividly contemplating the 27-year minimum sentence he was given in November 1988 and reflecting it didn't seem long for what he'd done.

But as we approach the date in 2014 when he will be eligible for parole, it needs to be remembered that, for its time, Justice George Hampel's sentence for Knight was a long one. Moreover, it was not - aside from reasonable objections of survivors and families of the dead - controversial.

At the pre-sentence hearings, the Crown didn't ask for Knight to be locked up for the term of his natural life and it didn't appeal against the 27-year minimum. Nor did politicians climb over each other promising to ensure he would never be released, as Ted Baillieu and Daniel Andrews are doing.

Saturday, July 30, 2011

Mandatory sentencing poisonous: Cowdery

Alison Savage | ABC Online | 29 July 2011

One of Australia's most high-profile prosecutors has launched a scathing attack on the Victorian Government's approach to sentencing.

The former New South Wales chief prosecutor Nicholas Cowdery QC has told a Law Institute conference in Melbourne, that the Baillieu Government is pushing for mandatory sentences for juvenile offences to achieve short-term political gains.

"We've digested it. We have found it to be poisonous and we've regurgitated it," he said.

Mr Cowdery says he can see why it is an attractive idea for politicians.

"Talking about punishing people for the wrongs that they do us makes them feel good and makes their voters feel good," he said.

"They think that these are going to be reflected in votes at the next election, which is really all that they're interested in."

Mr Cowdery says the principle of sentencing law is that the penalties must reflect the offence and the circumstances of the offender.

He says it has been proven that mandatory sentencing does not work.

"The electors need to know that what they're proposing and what they are doing doesn't produce the results that they hope it will," he said.

He says it makes even less sense when it comes mandatory sentences for teenagers who commit acts of violence.

"We know from experience that the best way of addressing criminality in juveniles is to remove the causes."

He has also labelled the Government's public survey on sentencing reform "bizarre."

'Sexting' youths placed on sex offenders register

Nicole Brady | The Age | July 24 2011

VICTORIAN teenagers caught with raunchy images of girls sent to them via ''sexting'' have been charged with child pornography offences and placed on the sex offender register, ruining their career options and branding them for years.

The cases have alarmed lawyers and youth advocates who are calling for urgent amendments to the law, which was designed to prevent paedophiles from associating with children, not ''punish teenagers' sexual curiosity''.

They want courts to be given discretionary power over who should be placed on the register.

Sexting involves people sending naked or revealing pictures of themselves via mobile phones or the internet to others.

Under the law, sexts are classified as child pornography when the images are of people under 18, even if the person pictured took the photographs themselves and willingly sent it to others. It is mandatory in Victoria for those over 18 found guilty of possessing or sending child pornography to be registered as a sex offender.

The Law Institute's criminal law section co-chair, James Dowsley, said the surge in the number of low-risk people being listed on the register meant police were being forced to supervise people who posed little or no risk to children, therefore compromising the monitoring of serious sex offenders.

The Sunday Age is aware of two recent cases in which teenagers were charged with pornography offences as a result of sexting. Both were placed on the register for eight years.

Friday, July 29, 2011

Juvenile sentencing plan draws fire

Simon Lauder | ABC The World Today | 29 July 2011

Audio here

ASHLEY HALL: The Victorian Government has hit back at critics of its plan to introduce a form of mandatory sentencing for the perpetrators of violent crimes.

A retired Supreme Court judge has told The World Today the Government's plan is dangerous and could lead to unjust penalties especially for juveniles.

It comes as the former New South Wales Director of Public Prosecutions Nicholas Cowdery also weighs in, calling the plan misconceived.

The Victorian Government says it's just delivering what the people want.

Simon Lauder reports.

SIMON LAUDER: The Coalition won government in Victoria with its promise to be tough on crime.

The Attorney-General Robert Clark says he plans to keep that promise. The Government is even inviting public input on its overhaul of sentencing laws through an online survey.

ROBERT CLARK: While the advice of experts and the opinions of interest groups are important the views of all Victorians are also important and we're giving Victorians the opportunity to have their say.

SIMON LAUDER: The plan to introduce minimum jail terms of two years for 16 and 17 year olds who are convicted of violent crimes has been slammed by social justice and law groups. Now it's attracting criticism from interstate.

The former New South Wales Director of Public Prosecutions Nicholas Cowdery QC told a conference in Melbourne this morning the policy is an attempt to buy votes.

NICHOLAS COWDERY: Talking about punishing people for the wrongs that they do to us makes them feel good and it makes their voters feel good. And they think that these are going to be reflected in votes at the next election which is really all that they are interested in.

SIMON LAUDER: As a Supreme Court judge Frank Vincent QC heard evidence about some of Victoria's most heinous crimes over more than two decades until his retirement two years ago.

FRANK VINCENT: The fixing of arbitrary minimums in any situation is an extremely dangerous course to adopt.

SIMON LAUDER: Mr Vincent says courts try to balance the seriousness of an offence and the circumstances of the offender when sentencing. He says without discretion a judge is in a very difficult position.

FRANK VINCENT: In relation to young people in particular the emphasis has generally been placed upon their immaturity at that time and the prospects of rehabilitation and so forth. It's a very difficult balance to strike in any situation.

Fixing of arbitrary minimum terms has about it a very serious potential for inappropriate sentencing and unjust sentencing.

SIMON LAUDER: Would it change some, not just sentences, do you think it would change judgements?

FRANK VINCENT: It would be very difficult. It would be hard to accommodate doing something that you as a judge had felt or felt was inherently wrong and socially destructive rather than being advantageous to the community and the individual concerned.

SIMON LAUDER: The Government also plans to introduce minimum sentences of four years for adults who commit violent crimes.

The Attorney-General Robert Clark says the mandatory periods will apply to all unless there are exceptional circumstances and they're yet to be determined.

ROBERT CLARK: Clearly you don't want to put anyone behind bars. But there are circumstances where people engage in violence that is so gross both in terms of its culpability and the degree of injuries inflicted that you need to put people behind bars both for effective deterrence and for the effect of protecting the community. And that's what the Government has committed to do.

SIMON LAUDER: But wouldn't your plan remove that discretion from a judge who is best placed having heard all the evidence?

ROBERT CLARK: Well as I say the offence is going to be carefully targeted to those examples of gross violence for which effectively there is no excuse - the deliberately planned attack, the stomping on incapacitated victims, the marauding gangs.

And then there will on top of that will be the option for genuinely exception circumstances.

But we've seen in Victoria in the past when the previous government legislated to allow unspecified exceptional circumstances when they have purported to abolish suspended sentences for serious crimes, that what was intended to be the exception became the rule. And that's what we are determined to ensure does not occur with this offence.

SIMON LAUDER: And why don't you believe that children, those under 18, should have their youth, immaturity and of course their positive potential taken into account?

ROBERT CLARK: Well that is already being taken into account in the fact that juveniles will be subject to a maximum period of two years detention compared with adults who will be subject to a maximum of four years, a minimum of four years detention.

But as I've said Magistrates Court, the Children's Court is already imposing sentences of between one and two years detention in more than half of the cases of juveniles convicted of intentionally causing serious injury. And that's not even having regard to the fact that our offence will be confined to instances of gross violence.

SIMON LAUDER: Victoria's Sentencing Advisory Council is due to deliver a report to government in September.

ASHLEY HALL: Simon Lauder.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Sentencing remarks of his Honour Magistrate Rosencwajg

DET SEN CONST HOGAN v DERRYN HINCH 

Melbourne Magistrates' Court 21 July 2001

[...]

[16] Indeed, it was on the basis of your medical condition, that you asked I impose a form of a suspended sentence of imprisonment.

[17] In doing so, you also acknowledged, in court, the irony of that submission, coming from a man who had publicly advocated the abolition of suspended sentences, and no doubt, to whatever degree, influenced the public and political debate on that issue. Legislation has recently been passed restricting the ability of the County and Supreme Courts to impose suspended prison sentences with the intention to extend these legislative provisions to this jurisdiction in the future.

[18] Your present situation before this court in fact highlights the significance of judicial discretion in the sentencing process and that each case has its unique factors requiring a balancing process which results in tailoring sentences to the distinct facts of the offence and the individual circumstances of the accused. A 'one size fits all' approach, without judicial discretion, will result in courts being transformed into vehicles for injustice.

[19] Solely for reason of your medical condition, I have had you assessed for a Home Detention Order which will permit you to serve your sentence of imprisonment in your home, subject to certain conditions. You have indicated that you are more than willing to accept such an order and indeed you have been assessed as suitable.

[20] Ironically, as we speak, a Bill is before Parliament which will amend the Sentencing Act and deprive courts of such a sentencing option. You may very well be the last person in this state to be sentenced to a HDO in its current form.

[21] It would be well for you to reflect on these matters when next you enter the public debate, as indeed you have in the past, on such issues as the abolition of suspended sentencing or even more pressing, the current issue of mandatory minimum sentences as contemplated by the government.

[...]

Derryn Hinch sentenced to home detention: Guilty of contempt for naming two sex offenders

Norrie Ross | The Herald Sun | 21 July 2011

A magistrate today ordered that Derryn Hinch, 67, serve five months of home detention for naming two serial sex offenders in breach of serious sex offender laws.

Magistrate Charlie Rozencwajg told Hinch today that he had several previous serious breaches of the law in his various "name and shame campaigns" over the years. Magistrate Rozencwajg made a number of conditions on the home detention order which will mean the "Human Headline" cannot communicate with his audience.

The magistrate said Hinch must not engage in gainful employment and must not use Facebook or Twitter or other social media to propagate his views. Hinch has also been ordered not to give media interviews and not to encourage others to pass on his views on his behalf.

Hinch was found guilty of five breaches of section 42 of the serious sexual offenders monitoring act by naming two rapists.

In his Melbourne Magistrates' Court sentence Mr Rozencwajg said the offences were committed in May, June and July 2008 when Hinch posted information on his website and publicly named the offender at a rally on the steps of state parliament.

"I would regard your actions as taking the law into your own hands and encouraging others to do the same," Mr Rozencwajg said.

The magistrate said that one of the ironies of the case was that HInch would probably be the last person in Victoria to be sentenced to home detention. He said that another irony was the fact that Hinch had campained for the abolishing of suspended sentences and encouraged the passing of a "one size fits all approach which removed judicial discretion" in sentencing.

Such an approach would lead to injustice, the magistrate said.

Mr Rozencwajg said that Hinch had a number of prior convictions for similiar offences but had not heeded the warnings given to him over the years about his conduct by various.

The magistrate said that if Hinch gave interviews to the massive media pack assembled at court today it would be in contravention of his order.

Hinch underwent a life-saving liver transplant earlier this month and was in hospital again yesterday to have a stent removed

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Legal aid warning on sentences for young

Adrian Lowe | The Age | 13 July 2011
VICTORIA Legal Aid has called on the state government to scrap its plans for statutory minimum sentences for some young offenders.
It says there could never be a mandatory sentencing regime that effectively limited risks of inappropriate jail time for young people.
The organisation has warned that strict mandatory sentences means that disproportionate sentences would be imposed for less serious offences and make court delays worse.
The government in May asked the Sentencing Advisory Council to consider its proposal to impose statutory minimum jail terms for assault offences that were committed with ''gross violence''.
The government plans that for adults, the minimum term would be four years, and for 16-year-olds and 17-year-olds, two years. Legal Aid, in its submission to the council, says there is ''overwhelming evidence'' that mandatory sentencing does not create safer communities, that ''rigid rules'' create injustice in individual cases and justice is best served by tailoring responses to each case and offender.
Attorney-General Robert Clark has previously said that the changes will affect only the worst offenders and it was important to send a message to the community that ''gross violence will have serious consequences''. The council's advice to the government is due in September.
Legal Aid funds representation for 76 per cent of accused people in serious criminal cases and almost all cases in the Children's Court.
It has recommended that mandatory sentencing can never be imposed that would effectively limit inappropriate imprisonment for young people. It has made 15 recommendations to ''avoid or limit the potential problems'' of the current proposal. ''While a prison term is plainly sometimes appropriate for children who commit very serious violent offences, those cases are generally not ones in which a sentence would need to be compelled to impose a mandatory sentence to achieve that outcome,'' the submission states. Other recommendations include:
■ If mandatory sentencing for young people is imposed, the minimum be much less than two years' jail.
■ That judges be able to abandon the mandatory minimum if satisfied it would be ''plainly unjust''.
■ Mandatory sentencing should apply only to intentional conduct, not reckless conduct.
Legal Aid said that while the government had the right to alter sentencing, the best ways to do so were through changing the maximum penalties for offences, altering the parole system or through baseline sentences.

Monday, July 11, 2011

African youth 'cop targets'

Stuart Rintoul | The Australian | 6 July 2011
YOUNG men of African descent experienced more difficulty with police than other youth, were less likely to have their rights respected and more likely to feel they had been racially targeted, according to a new report on Victorian police and race.
A 12-month study on racial profiling by the Flemington and Kensington Community Legal Centre, titled Race or Reason?, found young men of African descent were almost twice as likely as Australian-born youth to have been stopped and questioned by police in the past month.
The experience of young African men with police was "fraught with difficulties" and characterised by the use or threat of physical force or insulting language. Young men of African descent were more likely to be charged with minor offences.
Young African men reported feeling scared, angry and targeted and made to feel "small and dumb". Many felt they had been "cruelly treated".
Almost half (47.6 per cent) strongly felt they had been stopped by the police because of their race.
As a result, young men of African descent were noticeably more likely than any other ethnic group to worry about being stopped by the police when walking alone. Almost 30 per cent answered they were "not at all" able to walk down the street without worrying about such contact, compared to just 1.8 per cent of Australian-born youth.
Young women of African descent were also significantly likely to feel that police would be tougher on them than Australian-born women.
In May, the Victorian government agreed to a settlement with two African refugees who claimed they had been chased, beaten and abused by police officers.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Mandatory teen thug terms 'misguided'

Adrian Lowe | The Age | June 16, 2011
THE state government has been accused of being misguided over its plan for mandatory sentences for 16 and 17-year-olds convicted of violent crimes.
New figures show that the targeted offences make up less than 1 per cent of proven cases in the Children's Court, and a peak legal group has warned that the changes in the laws for adult offenders for the same crimes could lead to further delays in an already stretched County Court.
The government has requested advice from the Sentencing Advisory Council on its proposal to introduce statutory minimum jail terms for the crimes of intentionally causing serious injury and recklessly causing serious injury where the offender uses gross violence.
Adult offenders will be subject to a four-year statutory minimum jail term, while 16 and 17-year-olds face a minimum of two years' jail.
The council has recently released data showing that just 0.2 per cent of proven cases in the Children's Court involved intentionally causing serious injury between 2000 and 2009, and just 0.7 per cent involved recklessly causing serious injury.
The Law Institute of Victoria believes that those figures indicate the government is on the wrong track. ''The sentencing statistics alone indicate that such a severe reaction in terms of mandatory sentencing is not warranted,'' said James Dowsley, co-chairman of the institute's criminal law section.