Showing posts with label policing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label policing. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Neighbour can't cop jolly whistle

Gayle Bryant | Heckler | SMH | 5 September 2012

A FRIEND of mine was threatened with an AVO on the weekend. Now, what image has just come into your head? Some violent, uncontrollable loser who lets his fists do the talking? Some drunken yobbo? Try a gentle, non-aggressive man whose only crime is whistling.

No, my fingers didn't slip on the keyboard. I didn't mean to write that my friend enjoys ''wrestling'', or ''wrecking things'', or ''whacking people''. My friend likes to whistle. Not constantly. Just occasionally, when he feels good about the world and has a spring in his step.

On Saturday, however, he was amazed to find that not one, but three police had appeared on his doorstep to tell him his neighbour had complained about this habit. Apparently, my friend was told, his neighbour often hears him whistling as he walks up the path separating their two homes - and this is not OK. My friend was told he can whistle in his own home, but he must not whistle as he walks past his neighbour's front door.


Illustration: Simon Letch

Of all the noises that can be emitted by the body, I would have thought whistling is the least offensive. But now you can be threatened with an AVO if you purse and blow? What next? AVOs for burpers, farters or stomach grumblers?
Advertisement

Aren't AVOs served when someone is in fear for their safety? How does whistling fit into this category? It demeans their very purpose.

My friend has no intention of changing his behaviour. He told the police that he would see his neighbour in court before he stopped whistling. The fact that three police were sent to pass on the message only added fuel to the fire. Especially, as he pointed out to them, no police had yet responded to his calls to the same station about a stolen bike. I'm guessing a stolen bike hardly raises an eyebrow.

But the novelty of a whistling complaint clearly had the police scrambling for the squad car. They had probably never been called to serve an AVO against a whistler and weren't sure how the perpetrator would react. Perhaps they thought he'd launch an assault on their eardrums by whistling at extreme volume or deliberately off-key. Maybe they thought all the local dogs would come running, resulting in chaos.

Are we becoming so obsessed about being in control of the sounds we want to hear that those we can't control are cause for a complaint to the police? Come on Sydney, why not purse those lips and whistle down the street just as Mark Twain writes in Tom Sawyer, ''with a mouth full of harmony and a soul full of gratitude''.

Saturday, May 19, 2012

The NYPD's criminal stop-and-frisk record

Darius Charney | The Guardian |  15 May 2012 


A march earlier this month against the NYPD's stop-and-frisk policy, led by community leaders and Princeton University professor and activist Cornel West. Photograph: Scott Houston/Corbis

The police department's policy amounts to racial profiling and the illegal harassment of thousands of New Yorkers a day.

Last week, the New York Police Department released quarterly data on its stop-and-frisk program. The numbers are worse than ever, and they confirm everything that is wrong with this practice.

From January through March 2012, 203,500 New Yorkers were stopped and frisked. That's an average of 2,200 people per day. Twenty-two hundred people a day, many of whom are stopped for no reason – or the wrong reason, like the color of their skin, or their age, or their gender expression – patted down, sometimes roughed-up, intimidated, asked for ID in their own neighborhood, sometimes in their own buildings, asked to empty their pockets. Twenty-two hundred people a day stopped by police as they walk down the street on their way home, to school, the corner deli, or to see friends. Twenty-two hundred people a day asked to justify their presence in the city in which they live.

This is already an outrage; but if you look further at the numbers, it's even more outrageous. Despite years of public outcry and lawsuits, theNYPD is stopping even more people than in previous years. In 2011, the department stopped a record 685,724 New Yorkers, a 600% increase since Raymond Kelly took over as police commissioner in 2002. But the 2012 numbers are on track to be still worse. At the rate it's going, the NYPD will stop nearly three-quarters of a million New Yorkers in 2012.

Eight-seven per cent of the people stopped by the NYPD in the first quarter of 2012 were black or Latino, while only 54% of the city's population is black or Latino. Despite claims to the contrary, the data show that even when you take other factors into consideration – including crime rates –stops are disproportionately concentrated in black and Latino neighborhoods. And in all neighborhoods, blacks and Latinos are significantly more likely to be stopped than whites. The data also show that NYPD officers use physical force more often when stopping blacks and Latinos.

Stop-and-frisk, as practiced by the NYPD, amounts to racial profiling, which is illegal. It violates the 14th amendment of the US constitution, which prohibits racial discrimination, and the fourth amendment, which protects against unreasonable searches and seizures.

Stop-and-frisk also fails to make New Yorkers safer. There is an implied trade-off that New Yorkers are told to accept: OK, so the practice is intrusive and humiliating and it violates your rights, but it's necessary to fight crime. That is a lie. The vast majority of stop-and-frisks – 90%, in the first quarter of 2012 – do not uncover evidence of a crime. Less than 1% lead to recovery of guns, the supposed goal of the stop-and-frisk program.

The NYPD is not catching criminals; they are stopping and humiliating thousands of New Yorkers a day who have done nothing wrong.

There is no evidence that stop-and-frisk is responsible for the city's drop in crime rate in recent years. On the contrary, New Yorkers feel less safe and often have their lives upended by unlawful stops. Many communities, especially communities of color, feel that they are under siege. To them, the presence of police on the streets signals not protection against crime, but a danger of becoming the victims of a crime: being illegally stopped, harassed, possibly beat up.

The Center for Constitutional Rights is suing New York City to end these gross violations of hundreds, or thousands, of people's rights. Occupying entire neighborhoods and treating vast portions of the city's citizenry as suspects violates the US constitution and fundamental human rights.

Saturday, March 24, 2012

The force's new weapon of choice

Anna Patty, Lisa Davies | SMH | March 24, 2012



"It is almost like having your spinal cord severed" .... Lyn Shumack, psychologist. Photo: Craig Abraham

Tasers should not be used in place of communication skills. Anna Patty and Lisa Davies report.

The grainy black and white CCTV footage shows a young Brazilian man running from police before he is shocked by a Taser - a small snapshot of what led to his death.

As it was replayed over and again on internet and television broadcasts, it encouraged viewers to form their own opinions about the rights and wrongs of Taser use.

Reports about the trivial circumstances of 21-year-old Roberto Laudisio Curti's alleged crime - snatching a mere packet of biscuits from a convenience store - and the recent death of both his parents, who were taken by cancer, his youth and promise, made just one thing clear. This was a tragic waste of life.

But questions remain unanswered about whether the Taser was inappropriately used and whether it directly caused the young man's death.

Did he fall and hit his head? Did he have a heart attack? Did multiple firings of the Taser's 50,000 volt-charged pellets kill him? A coronial inquest will soon tell.

The circumstances in which the young police officers drew and fired their Tasers, in the knowledge that each move and sound they made would be captured on a small video camera attached to their Taser, is still unknown. This will be the subject of a investigation to be overseen by the NSW Ombudsman, Bruce Barbour.

At the height of an emotionally-charged debate over the use of Taser guns, Mr Barbour is completing the most comprehensive review of Taser use in Australia, analysing how the device was used more than 1600 times in NSW from October 2008 to November 2010.

During that period, fewer than 30 official complaints were made.

''There are a number of examples publicly discussed already where police have believed that the Taser use was appropriate and where we and magistrates or courts have said we don't think it was appropriate in those circumstances,'' Mr Barbour said. After an earlier review in 2008, he recommended a two-year moratorium before Tasers were widely circulated to allow for the development of protocols, taking into account lessons learned from overseas.

''Unfortunately the government at the time decided they wouldn't follow that course and decisions were made in quick succession to make more Tasers available and to roll them out to all general duties officers,'' Mr Barbour said. ''More than 15,000 police are trained in the use of Tasers in NSW and we have more than 1100 Tasers in use - the most anywhere in the country.''

In response to the overseas experience, Mr Barbour warned of a trend known as ''mission creep'', where police use Tasers in low-risk situations to gain compliance. One woman in the US was shocked by a Taser after refusing to follow a police order to get out of bed.

''We don't want to see police lose the skill to effectively communicate in situations to de-escalate rather than simply resorting to options they have around use of force like capsicum spray and Tasers,'' Mr Barbour said.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

False arrest claim against police sparks self-defence laws debate

Louis Andrews | The Canberra Times | March 5, 2012

A Canberra man is suing police for unlawfully arresting him, manhandling him, spraying him with capsicum spray and leaving him languishing in a cell for 10 hours.

It's a case that's sparked political debate, with the Greens accusing Attorney-General Simon Corbell of tabling a bill ''based on a false premise''.

But the Attorney-General has rejected the charge, arguing the Greens have misunderstood the way self-defence laws operate.

Two police protection bills - one from government and one from the opposition - are on hold after the legal community raised fears legal rights could be stripped.

The issue will now come under scrutiny twice: in a Legislative Assembly committee and by a separate body of academics and law enforcement experts.

Meanwhile, lawyers for Danny Andrew Klobucar have filed papers in the ACT Supreme Court accusing the Australian Federal Police and the arresting officer of negligence.

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Broken Windows: the police and neighborhood safety

George L. Kelling | James Q. Wilson | The Atlantic | Mar 1, 1982



In the mid-1970s The State of New Jersey announced a "Safe and Clean Neighborhoods Program," designed to improve the quality of community life in twenty-eight cities. As part of that program, the state provided money to help cities take police officers out of their patrol cars and assign them to walking beats. The governor and other state officials were enthusiastic about using foot patrol as a way of cutting crime, but many police chiefs were skeptical. Foot patrol, in their eyes, had been pretty much discredited. It reduced the mobility of the police, who thus had difficulty responding to citizen calls for service, and it weakened headquarters control over patrol officers.

Many police officers also disliked foot patrol, but for different reasons: it was hard work, it kept them outside on cold, rainy nights, and it reduced their chances for making a "good pinch." In some departments, assigning officers to foot patrol had been used as a form of punishment. And academic experts on policing doubted that foot patrol would have any impact on crime rates; it was, in the opinion of most, little more than a sop to public opinion. But since the state was paying for it, the local authorities were willing to go along.

Five years after the program started, the Police Foundation, in Washington, D.C., published an evaluation of the foot-patrol project. Based on its analysis of a carefully controlled experiment carried out chiefly in Newark, the foundation concluded, to the surprise of hardly anyone, that foot patrol had not reduced crime rates. But residents of the foot patrolled neighborhoods seemed to feel more secure than persons in other areas, tended to believe that crime had been reduced, and seemed to take fewer steps to protect themselves from crime (staying at home with the doors locked, for example). Moreover, citizens in the foot-patrol areas had a more favorable opinion of the police than did those living elsewhere. And officers walking beats had higher morale, greater job satisfaction, and a more favorable attitude toward citizens in their neighborhoods than did officers assigned to patrol cars.

Monday, December 12, 2011

Lawyers fear rise in use of capsicum spray

Alison Caldwell | ABC Online |  5 December 2011

Lawyers in Victoria say they fear recent changes to the Victoria Police manual could lead police to use capsicum spray or foam more often.

Capsicum spray, also known as pepper spray, is a crowd control weapon which makes the skin and eyes sting and burn.

The spray has been in the news worldwide because of the Occupy protests and two police officers in California were recently suspended after they used the spray on protesting university students.

AUDIO: Concerns police will use capsicum spray more often (PM)

Police in Victoria have been using the spray on offenders since 1998.

Until recently the police manual provided guidelines for the use of capsicum spray, including when it should and should not be used on a person.

The manual used to state the spray or foam should not be used "when a person is passively resisting arrest such as hanging limp or refusing to comply with instructions."

But that guideline was removed from the police manual last year.

Melbourne lawyer Anthony Kelly, from the Flemington and Kensington Community Legal Centre, says he is concerned police will start to use capsicum spray more liberally.

"Our major concerns are that when capsicum spray was first introduced it was very clearly specified that it should only be used in really violent or confrontational situations of serious physical confrontation," he said.

"But more and more we're seeing the use of capsicum spray against people who are simply non-compliant with police orders - so against prisoners, against people in custody, but also against protesters who are peaceful and are engaged in what's sometimes called passive resistance or non-violent civil disobedience.

"Prior to February last year there were very clear guidelines that it should only be used in situations of violence and serious physical confrontation ... and those guidelines have now been removed from the recent edition.

"We're concerned that police are more likely to use capsicum spray against people who are engaged in non-violent protest, peaceful protest."

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Let's admit it: most police work does not involve catching criminals

Robert Reiner | The Guardian | 28 October 2011


The view of policing as primarily concerned with catching criminals raises false expectations about tackling crime and neglects what people in practice demand from the police. Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PA

The Bill got it right – what unites the bewildering miscellany of police jobs is the use of legitimate force

For decades, policy makers and criminologists have agonised over whether the police were fundamentally a force or a service. On one hand, research on what the police did, and on what the public called on the police to do, showed that much if not most of their work did not involve the use of their law enforcement powers. On the other, media representations and the culture of the police rank and file saw "real" police work as crime fighting.

Analytically, this conundrum was resolved by the theory formulated by the American sociologist Egon Bittner. The police officer was "Florence Nightingale in pursuit of Willie Sutton" (a legendary bank robber). What united the bewildering miscellany of police jobs, from riot control to letting in householders who'd lost their keys, was that they potentially required the use of legitimate force. The police were the domestic organisation in which was concentrated the Leviathan state's monopoly of legitimate force. They were "equipped, entitled and required to deal with every exigency in which force may have to be used". They were "the fire to fight fire", using tainted means to resolve emergencies when this was necessary. Or as a 1992 episode of The Bill put it: "Force is part of the service."

Policy debates about policing have changed fundamentally in the past 20 years. For once, the shift can be dated quite precisely. It was made explicit in the police reform white paper published in 1993. Section 2.2 stated: "The main job of the police is to catch criminals." The rub came in the very next sentence: "In a typical day, however, only about 18% of calls to the police are about crime."

The view of policing as primarily concerned with catching criminals is utterly misconceived. It raises false expectations about what the police can do about crime, condemns them to a quixotic quest beyond their capacity, and neglects what people in practice demand from the police. Its apparent obviousness derives largely from media representations, the main source of "information" about crime and policing for most people. Media stories (both news and fictional) focus overwhelmingly on successful police investigations of very serious violent crimes, especially murder, which form only a small part of the police workload. And the police are spectacularly less successful in clearing up crimes than media stories suggest: far fewer than 2% of crimes result in a conviction.

Friday, September 2, 2011

Do we have a fundamental right to film the police in public?

Hugh Tomlinson QC | The Guardian | 31 August 2011

English case law is unclear, but rulings in the US and Strasbourg suggest we do have a right to photograph public officials

As a number of recent cases have made clear, filming policing activity in public places is a vital method of holding police to account. But there have been continuing tensions between the police and photographers over the practice. In January 2010 there was a protest in Trafalgar Square by photographers against the use of terrorism laws to stop and search photographers. A campaign called "I'm a photographer, not a terrorist" was launched to protect the rights of those taking photographs in public places.

However, although guidance issued by, for example, the Metropolitan Police has made it clear that
"Members of the public and the media do not need a permit to film or photograph in public places and police have no power to stop them filming or photographing incidents or police personnel"
this often does not appear to have come to the attention of individual police officers (or security guards).

There have been some successful complaints about the use of police powers to prevent photography (see, for example, the complaint by Jess Hurd) but there is no English case law on the relationship between the right to take photographs of the police and freedom of expression. Advances in technology has meant that the legal issues have arisen in a number of different jurisdictions (see "Is filming the police a felony or a right?").

In this context, a recent decision from the United States is of considerable interest. In the case of Glik v Cunniffe (26 August 2011) the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit held that there is a First Amendment right to record police activity in public. Glik was arrested on 1 October 2007, after openly using his mobile phone to record three police officers arresting a suspect on Boston Common. He was charged with criminal violation of the Massachusetts wiretap act, aiding the escape of a prisoner and disturbing the peace. The charges were dismissed but, with the assistance of ACLU, Mr Glik brought a claim alleging, inter alia, that the police officers violated his First Amendment right to record police activity in public. The Judge refused to dismiss the claim on the basis of qualified immunity and the Court of Appeals dismissed the police appeal holding that
"Glik was exercising clearly-established First Amendment rights in filiming the officers in a public space, and that his clearly-established Fourth Amendment rights were violated by his arrest without probable cause."
It was noted that
"Gathering information about government officials in a form that can readily be disseminated to others serves a cardinal First Amendment interest in protecting and promoting "the free discussion of governmental affairs".
The court's conclusion will resonate with photography campaigners in this country:
"A citizen's right to film government officials, including law enforcement officers, in the discharge of their duties in a public space is a basic, vital, and well-established liberty safeguarded by the First Amendment."
The Citizen Media Law Project and the Thomas Jefferson Center have posts about the case.

Although First Amendment jurisprudence is not always consistent with the approach of the English or European Courts, the principles set out in this case are ones which appear to be consistent with the Convention's approach. The importance of the right to gather information for the purposes of promoting public debate has been repeatedly recognised by the Strasbourg court and strongly suggests that there is a fundamental right to take photographs of the activities of public officials - particularly police officers.

Monday, July 11, 2011

African youth 'cop targets'

Stuart Rintoul | The Australian | 6 July 2011
YOUNG men of African descent experienced more difficulty with police than other youth, were less likely to have their rights respected and more likely to feel they had been racially targeted, according to a new report on Victorian police and race.
A 12-month study on racial profiling by the Flemington and Kensington Community Legal Centre, titled Race or Reason?, found young men of African descent were almost twice as likely as Australian-born youth to have been stopped and questioned by police in the past month.
The experience of young African men with police was "fraught with difficulties" and characterised by the use or threat of physical force or insulting language. Young men of African descent were more likely to be charged with minor offences.
Young African men reported feeling scared, angry and targeted and made to feel "small and dumb". Many felt they had been "cruelly treated".
Almost half (47.6 per cent) strongly felt they had been stopped by the police because of their race.
As a result, young men of African descent were noticeably more likely than any other ethnic group to worry about being stopped by the police when walking alone. Almost 30 per cent answered they were "not at all" able to walk down the street without worrying about such contact, compared to just 1.8 per cent of Australian-born youth.
Young women of African descent were also significantly likely to feel that police would be tougher on them than Australian-born women.
In May, the Victorian government agreed to a settlement with two African refugees who claimed they had been chased, beaten and abused by police officers.

Sunday, July 10, 2011

'Racist' stop-and-search powers to be challenged

Vikram Dodd | The Guardian | 8 July 2011 
Court gives woman go-ahead to take controversial section 60 to task over allegations it discriminates against black people
The high court has agreed that a full legal challenge can be brought against a police stop-and-search power alleged to be used in a racist way against African-Caribbean people.
The challenge follows officers stopping and searching a 37-year-old woman with no convictions, after they claimed she was holding onto her bag in a suspicious way.
The woman, Ann Roberts, ended up being held down by officers on the floor in front of other people, handcuffed and taken to a police station where she was wrongly accused of being a class A drug user and placed on a treatment programme under the threat of arrest if she failed to attend.
Roberts was stopped under section 60 of the 1994 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act, brought in to tackle illegal raves. The power allows police to stop and search people without having a reasonable suspicion they are involved in criminality.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Politicians still dancing to the beat of the blue light disco

by Alex Mitchell, SMH, 22 January 2011:
YOU can always tell when a state election is imminent because the NSW cops suddenly become furiously proactive.
On past form, an unusually large number of raids will take place in the next few weeks and no expense will be spared to obtain photographs and footage of all the excitement.
The media will be flooded with pro-police stories, while the Police Association of NSW will start menacing politicians with a shopping list of new laws, more specialised equipment, extra recruitment and even more generous working conditions.
For the past 16 years of Labor rule, the high-pressure tactic has worked. Whatever the police wanted, they got because the government was determined to keep the cops “on side”.
Former premier Bob Carr had a simple electoral rule: don't let the Liberals outflank us on law and order. Thus the police received Glocks, Tasers, helicopters, a water cannon and much more.

Copland

By Jack Marx, news.com.au, 19 January 2011:
Everywhere one goes today, one hears the sound of regular people either outraged or bewildered by the leering presence of authority. There are cops with dogs at Newtown Station, making sure nobody’s got any fun in their pockets, faux cops at Sydney’s Luna Park, making sure nobody photographs the children, and uniformed baboons at your local pub, keeping alive the latter-day Aussie tradition that every peaceful night out must feature at least one ridiculous altercation with a bouncer. Just last week, a jog around my local athletics track was interrupted by a council worker, draped, naturally, in the harness of modern beautness, who demanded – I kid you not – that I cease my athletic behaviour lest I wear out the grass for others who might wish to engage in future athletic behaviour. With Australia Day approaching, it’s worth having a quick think about Australia’s apparent love affair with being told what to do. 
Most Australians are proud of the fact that this nation was born of convict stock. But this most over-jerked take on our history overlooks a somewhat uncomfortable truth – that one in five of the “first Australians” were effectively cops. In all of history, there is perhaps no nation that began its life so top heavy with authority, a whopping 20 per cent of the population licensed to bully, dob and sticky beak on the others, their careers enhanced by doing so in a hierarchical system in which the only possibility for advancement was through brown-nosing to one’s superiors.